Note:If this is your first time to visit this site, you might want to take a look at the rules of the game first. If you would prefer to respond directly to a statement made in the text, you should choose a persona and begin there.
Instructions | ||
---|---|---|
Below is a
list, alphabetically by e-mail address (the only information required
to participate in a dialogue here) of all the repsonses
received. You may respond to the participants in several ways.
|
||
E-mail addresses | Ref. no. | Arguments |
benda@s867.thu.edu.tw | Gorgias 57 | Weaving is _not necessarily_ concerned with the making of garments only. One could make other things by weaving--decorations, for example. |
bjeter@dfw.net | Gorgias 59 | Music, sir is concerned with the maturation of the soul. |
daveR@utarlg.uta.edu David Rieder, graduate student University of Texas at Arlington |
Polus 311 | Polus, Socrates is going to take you for a ride! All he is going to do is take your idea qua GENUS and devalue it to the level of a SPECIES. By doing this, he can subsequently set up a new genus by which to redescribe any notion you might have thought true. |
dddavis@visi.net Diane Davis, professor Old Dominion University |
Gorgias 63 | Rhetoric is not simply concerned with "discourse," which is, presumably what you'd like me to answer. It is, rather, a worldview. If a philosophic perspective would seek the truth, a rhetorical perception would look at how language is working to produce what functions as truth. |
rimbaud1@juno.com David D. Robbins, graduate student Valparaiso University School of Law |
Gorgias 1 | I may be a shoemaker, but as all humans, I am and contain many multitudes. That which you wish to call me is of no difference for I will always be those things which I am. As you will be what you will. In this I can profess being of many arts. But this too is of no difference because to profess may be to claim skill. My skill can only be judged by others. What I may profess as my skill may just be rendered mere folly in another's mind. What do you believe my skill to be? |